RESIDENCE HALL RULES: Sometimes they don't make sense

by Nathan Harris


Nate, put down that spatula before it's too late!

We all know that there is a blanket of rules covering us as students at a university as big as MSU, sometimes several, and the weight of it all on top of you can get stifling sometimes. I know for a fact that this happens, rules exerting their influence in areas of life where they have no business. I know because I have recently experienced this in my own way. 

Warm weather a few weeks ago prompted me to make an impulse decision and buy a charcoal grill at Meijer. A grill, back of charcoal, and grill matches. Innocent, I know.

I assembled it, took it outside, then broke it in, cooking up a few pieces of meat. A couple weeks later, I fired it up again, so to speak, to cook sausages and shish kebabs. I ran into some trouble, though, when a university official came outside on to the sidewalk and tells me that I am not allowed to grill, outside, on the sidewalk. 

After saying that I could not put away a brazier of burning charcoal, a compromise was reached where I would move across the parking lot (where I was still not allowed to cook out in the open air), finish as fast as possible, and make the grill disappear forever. 

Now, I didn’t take the possibility of an out and offer her a kebab, but the events got me thinking; first asking myself if there were anti-grilling rules on the books somewhere, and second, what some of the mechanics of the system were. 

The University Housing Terms and Conditions seemed to fit with what I had been told. “Charcoal grills, lighters, and propane gas tanks cannot be used on campus, except for MSU personnel.” 

The MSU Student Handbook and Resource Guide, which “includes rules…that have been established in the interest of intellectual and personal development,” tells a different story. In the interest of some kind of development, the handbook says, “No person shall set a fire upon property governed by the Board, except in approved stoves, or in grills in designated picnic area.” 

This doesn’t really help me grill outside the door in Brody, but it is definitely not the same as “…except for MSU personnel.” I don’t see solely employees of the university grilling behind Van Hoosen Hall, where there are designated picnic/grill areas. 

The point is not complaining about being told I can’t do what I want, though I don’t know the last time I’ve had myself a better bratwurst. The point in incongruous university policy whether due to poor communication at various levels, ad hoc rule-making, or some cosmic chaos theory that prevents a grand unified set of guidelines from existing. This is only one small example, but sometimes, the rules just don’t make sense.