|
About us
THE SPARTANEDGE MANIFESTO: The future of online
campus news is now
by Bonnie Bucqueroux, Publisher
(click here for PDF version)
The MSM are in trouble
Mainstream media (MSM) are in turmoil. Newspaper
readership continues to decline, as fewer and fewer young people
acquire the newspaper habit as they grow up. The Wall Street Journal cited
a Newspaper Association of America study that showed newspaper
circulation peaked
in
1984,
dropping
13% since then, as ad revenues remained stagnant.
At the same time, local TV broadcasters are watching
their viewership and their profits erode. The
Project for Excellence in Journalism found
that 72% of local TV stations saw a decline in viewers between 1998 and
2002. This despite the fact that most 18- to 34-year-olds still list
TV as their primary source of news.
What young people want
Young people in the United States are as bright and educated as they
have ever been. So what kind of news do they want (and need) and where
will they get it? And where will the next generation of eager young reporters
and editors find jobs in the field?
The answer in both cases is on the Internet. A 2005
Carnegie Corporation of America study called "Abandoning the News"
found that roughly half of all young people
said that
the Web is the most useful way to learn new information and it gave them “news
only when I want it.” Young people are increasingly abandoning “old
media” in favor of receiving information and entertainment through
desktops, laptops, cell phones and iPods hooked to the Internet.
But traditional news organizations are learning
that moving their traditional news products onto the Internet is no guarantee
of success.
More than 47 million people visited a newspaper Web site in September
2005, according
to the Newspaper Association of America, but young people
do not want the same-old/same-old. The most engaged young people
are indeed getting their news from TV, but their source is
more
likely to be Jon Stewart’s “Daily Show” than traditional
broadcast or cable news shows. An
Annenberg study during
the last presidential election cycle showed that “Daily Show” viewers
scored highest on a quiz about the candidates and their issues. Savvy
young people want news with an edge, with humor, with a point of view.
Another challenge in migrating news onto the web is that
traditional news outlines typically produce only a single slice of
the multimedia pie. Newspapers offer text, photos and illustrations, but no sound or moving images.
Radio offers sound only. TV is compelling because of its images and sound,
but it cannot offer the richness and depth of information that printed
words provide.
The Internet allows you to blend all these formats together into
a new mix, combining text, photos, illustrations, animations, video and audio. Want to watch the hurricane
hit land? Just click on the video clip – maybe it's footage
from a citizen journalist at the scene. Are you on a slow connection
or a cell phone? Then click on the slide show of pictures from
the scene instead.
Do you want to explore whether the increase in hurricanes
is linked to global warming? Click on our in-depth text article, illustrated
with a cool Flash animation that graphs the history of hurricanes in
the Gulf of Mexico. Or download the podcast of a noted
scientist that you can listen to later. A single Web site today can offer news in (1) all of the prevailing formats, (2)
all at the same time, (3) all in one place.
That kind of one-stop-media-format shopping can be compelling. Yet what
makes the Web the most spectacular media distribution system even are
its hyperlinks and interactivity. Hyperlinking allow you to bounce from
place to place, inside and outside an individual Web site. If you want to know even more about global
warming, our site should be smart enough to offer you a batch of
links to the best research on the Web worldwide. The good news as well is that the more
our sites links to other credible sites – and the more they link
back to us – the more all of those sites rise to the top in all-important
search engines like Google, so that even more people who care about the
topic can find us.
Interactivity gives visitors a chance to have their say and say it right
now. Have an opinion about the politics of global warming? Leave a comment
after our articles or join our forum or listserv. We may have a moderator
to ensure civility, but everyone worldwide has the chance to participate.
Are you an expert? Then maybe you should contribute to the wiki on global
warming that our site is building or that we can link you to.
Traditional news is a monologue, not a dialogue. Yes, you can write
a Letter to the Editor. But it will appear days later, if at all. It
may also be cut and edited beyond all recognition. And, yes,
you can always throw something at the TV screen. But that’s far less satisfying than
venting your spleen in a blog that allows others to respond in real time.
There are now an estimated
1.3 million bloggers in the United States
and 30%
of the general public now reports having read a blog. Most
blogs are less-than-newsworthy personal commentaries. However, the political
power of blogging cannot be ignored. In the last election cycle, the
conservative “pajamahedin” political bloggers who challenged
CBS’ reporting on George Bush’s National Guard record arguably
forced Dan Rather’s speedy retirement and the sacking of producer
Mary Mapes.
What will the future might look like
The two biggest limitations for Web news right now are imagination and
the lack of a certifiably profitable business model.
And while major news corporations might disagree, the failure of imagination
is the real barrier. If we learn how to build compelling news portals
that people love, there will always be ways to support them. Maybe not
at the 30% profit levels that today’s mega-news-corporations and
their stockholders currently demand. And it may mean relying
more on freelance citizen journalists than the full-time
staffers of today. But the economic model will emerge.
Again, the real barrier is imagination. We
have only begun to envision the Web news of the future.
Traditional news organizations, for the most part, are stuck in the mode
of shoveling existing content onto the web, with
little effort spent on making it more engaging and interactive.
When prodded to add a little video, newspaper sites often respond by
ordering already stressed reporters to generate a few
seconds of video while they are on scene. With little or no training,
marginal equipment and no extra
pay, no wonder the results range from uninspired to dismal.
Some newspapers join forces with a local TV station to produce a joint
Web site where they both shovel their existing product. Rarely do they
do more that add a survey or maybe an e-mail address for feedback.
A few news organizations are trying to re-think the delivery of news
in an online environment. The exceptional Bonita News < http://www.bonitanews.com> offers
cutting-edge design and multimedia. MLive < http://www.mlive.com> ,
the Booth Newspaper Web portal for its Michigan newspapers, has found
a solid niche offering news and interactive commentary on sports, particularly
high-school sports. They are now in the process of conceptualizing what
a statewide newspaper online would look like, with multimedia content
flowing from its stable of existing Michigan newspapers. The Detroit
News is breaking new ground with its political multi-blog, where a stable
of commentators offer content for free < http://info.detnews.com/weblog>
.
One of the many beauties of the Web, however, is that it
still offers the little guy affordable access to the field to try out
new ideas. You cannot start a new daily newspaper or TV station without risking millions of dollars, if you are lucky enough
to have them to spare. But the bloggers at Raw Story have broken major national news on the Plamegate
scandal in Washington with a monthly budget of $250. Chances are, the upstarts rather
than the corporate giants have the imagination to invent this new future.
The SpartanEdge.com challenge
SpartanEdge.com has an opportunity to help invent this new future. It
benefits from serving the Michigan State University community of students,
faculty and staff -- a real community. It also benefits from
being its ability to draw reporters, editors, photographers,
videographers, animators,
cartoonists and bloggers from a pool of talented, enthusiastic, energetic
young people. Some of these young volunteers will be the ones who push
the boundaries of what Web journalism can do.
How will the SpartanEdge.com site be different? All we can do is promise
that it will be an incubator of new ideas. It will launch spring
semester 2006, with news, features, streaming video, forums, surveys,
blogs, podcasts and maybe a wiki or two. What it will contain by the
end of that semester will depend on our collective imagination and our
resources (little or no money, some equipment, software and server space,
but lots of energy and imagination).
Our mission is to provide the online campus news of the future now.
We have a vision that blends media convergence with interactivity
in innovative ways that engage visitors. Our values include a commitment
to creativity, accuracy and a strong point of view, with a bit of irreverence
thrown in for good measure.
We cannot promise to be comprehensive
but we can guarantee that we care about the stories we offer -- and
hope that you will, too.
Will you join us? We need visitors, contributors and advertisers (and
feedback from all three). This is your chance to help us invent the future
-- now.
|